Gyara fim wanda yake kusa da asalin labarin koyaushe yana samun yardar masu sukar fim. Amma masu kallo suna da abubuwan da suke so, don haka ra'ayoyi game da hoto ɗaya koyaushe ana adawa da shi gaba ɗaya. Mun zaɓi fim ɗin da masu sukar ke so amma masu sauraro suka ƙi. Kuma sun yi kokarin tsara dalilan sabani tsakanin jama'a da masana daga duniyar sinima.
Lolita 1997
- Salo: Wasan kwaikwayo, Soyayya
- Kimantawa: KinoPoisk - 7.6, IMDb - 6.9
- Darakta: Adrian Line
Fim din abin kunya, wanda ya dogara da littafin Nabokov, ya samar da karamin ofishi a ofishin akwatin. Da fari dai, da kyar aka nuna shi a sinima, saboda suna tsoron mummunan ra'ayi daga al'umma. Tabbas, bisa ga makircin, soyayya ta taso tsakanin yarinya 'yar shekara 12 da wani saurayi. Abu na biyu, masu kallo kansu ba su da sha'awar kallon 'yanci mara kyau. Amma masu sharhi sun yaba da sauya fim din, suna masu kallon shi mafi kyau a wancan lokacin.
Leken Asiri yara 2001
- Salo: sci-fi, aiki
- Kimantawa: KinoPoisk - 6.6, IMDb - 5.5
- Daraktan: Robert Rodriguez
Mafi yawan al'amuran ban sha'awa lokacin da masu sauraro suke tsammanin fim ɗin wawa ne da ban dariya. Kuma masu sukar fim, akasin haka, suna ɗaukar ainihin ra'ayin fim ɗin da aiwatar da shi da inganci ƙwarai. Yi hukunci da kanka: an sace iyaye, tsoffin 'yan leƙen asiri, kuma' ya'yansu za su ceci uba da mahaifiya. Suna da tarin kayan leken asiri a cikin kayan ajiyar su, wanda suke fara amfani dashi. A sakamakon haka, ra'ayin masu kallon fina-finai ya kai 5.5, kuma na masu sukar - 93%.
Peter Pan 2003
- Salo: Fantasy, Romance
- Kimantawa: KinoPoisk - 7.4, IMDb - 6.8
- Daraktan: P.J. Hogan
Masu sukar juna sun fafata da juna don yaba fim ɗin da ya shahara da sananniyar tatsuniyar. Suna son komai: duka abubuwan gani da daidaito na fim na ainihin labarin. Har ila yau, masu sauraro suna da wannan tatsuniya tsakanin waɗanda suka fi so, amma masu sauraro sam ba su son ’yan wasan. Halin da kawai za'a iya gane shi shine Jason Isaacs, wanda ya buga Lucius Malfoy a cikin Harry Potter. Sabili da haka, ana nuna hoton sau da yawa a silima ɗin da babu komai a ciki.
Karkashin Fata (2013)
- Salo: Horror, fantasy
- Kimantawa: KinoPoisk - 5.8, IMDb - 6.3
- Daraktan: Jonathan Glazer
Wani fim din nishadi wanda masu suka suke kaunarsa, amma masu kallo suna kiyayya. Masanan sun ba hoton kwatankwacin kashi 85%, suna la'akari da shi ta fuskar tunani da ban sha'awa. A cikin ra'ayi na masu sauraro, wasan kwaikwayo na gani yana gudana akan allo. Babu wata alaƙa tsakanin abin da ke faruwa, makircin ya daɗe kuma yana da ƙarfi, kuma fitattun 'yan wasa ba sa “ja da” matsayinsu. A wata kalma, hoton bai shiga cikin masu sauraro ba.
Kaisar ya daɗe! (Hail, Kaisar!) 2016
- Salo: Wasan kwaikwayo, Ban dariya
- Kimantawa: KinoPoisk - 6.6, IMDb - 6.3
- Daraktan: Ethan Coen, Joel Coen
Rakodin tarihin 'yan uwan Coen ya hada da mutum-mutumin Oscar guda 4, wanda ke magana game da girmama jama'a da kuma son masu sukar fim. Amma masu sauraro sun fahimci wannan hoton a matsayin mara nasara. A ra'ayinsu, nassoshin da ba za a iya fahimta ba game da wasu ayyukan suna sanya maƙarƙashiyar makircin da ya riga ya zama mafi rikitarwa. Sabili da haka, tallan ofis ɗin ba ta burge ba. Amma masu sukar sun haɗu cikin farin ciki, suna la'akari da hoton ya cancanci. Kuma makircin ya kasance mai rikitarwa musamman ga mai kallo mai tunani.
Rayuwar David Gale 2003
- Salo: Mai ban sha'awa, Drama
- Kimantawa: KinoPoisk - 8.1, IMDb - 7.6
- Daraktan: Alan Parker
Wani sabanin ra'ayoyi mabambanta na masu suka, wanda kimarsu ta kai 19%, da kuma masu kallo wadanda suka daga darajar zuwa 7.6. Masu sukar lamura ba sa son cikakkun bayanai, lokacin wuce gona da iri, da makircin da ake iya faɗi. Masu sauraro, a gefe guda, sun kasance cikin mamakin makomar jarumai, da sauye-sauyen da ba zato ba tsammani, da kuma tsammanin tashin hankali. Don haka, hoton ya zama abin birgewa kuma ya kafu sosai cikin zaɓin masu kallon fim.
Nuhu 2014
- Salo: Drama, Kasada
- Kimantawa: KinoPoisk - 6.7, IMDb - 5.7
- Daraktan: Darren Aronofsky
A cewar masu kallo, fassarar kyauta ba abar karɓa ba ce a al'amuran imani. Jirgin Nuhu labari ne na littafi mai tsarki, kuma karbuwarsa mai yuwuwa ne idan ka bi daidai sakonnin. Sabili da haka, hoton bai zama fitacce ba, tunda yana ƙunshe da fassarar kyauta kuma ya cika da cuta. Masu sukar sun fi nuna goyon baya ga daidaitawar fim, suna gaskanta cewa darektan da 'yan wasan sun sami nasarar isar da ma'anar Littafi Mai Tsarki daidai.
Lieutenant mara kyau: Port of Call - New Orleans 2009
- Salo: Drama, Laifi
- Kimantawa: KinoPoisk - 6.5, IMDb - 6.6
- Darakta: Werner Herzog
Wani fim ɗin "tunani" wanda masu sukar ke kauna, amma masu kallo sun ƙi. A cikin labarin, wani dan sanda da ke sayar da kwayoyi ya sami sabon aiki. Amma zai iya cika shi, tunda ya shiga cikin mugunta har ma fiye da masu laifi. Masu sauraro sun ji cewa jarumin ba shi da amfani, kuma fim ɗin kansa yana da wuyar ganewa. Masu sukar lamiri, a gefe guda, mahaukaci ne game da hoton, sun ba shi kashi 85% na kuri'un.
